• CONTACT Ji
  • DONATE to Ji
Jewish InteractiveJewish InteractiveJewish InteractiveJewish Interactive
  • Products & Services
    • Ji Products & Services
    • Jigzi
      • Jigzi Pro Tips
      • Jigzi Training
    • Curriculum Series
      • Ji Alef-Bet: Hebrew Reading Curriculum
      • Hebrew Reading Fast Track
      • Ivrit Misaviv La’Olam – עברית מסביב לעולם
        • Playful Blended Hebrew Learning – Mini Courses
      • Shabbat Interactive
      • My Online Siddur
      • Ji Israel Bytes
      • Tales of Jerusalem – ילדים מספרים ירושלים
    • Ji Prime
    • The Ji Collection (Apps)
      • Ji Studio
      • Ji Calendar
      • My Menorah
      • Sukkah Challenge
      • Make it Grow-Tu Bishvat
      • Alef Bet Wheel
      • Mitzvah Hunt
      • iThankYou – Modeh Ani
    • Training & Support
      • Upcoming Training
      • Jigzi Training
      • Playful Blended Hebrew Learning – Mini Courses
  • Teachers
    • Teachers
    • Educator resources
    • Professional Development with Ji
      • Upcoming Training
      • Jigzi Training
      • Playful Blended Hebrew Learning – Mini Courses
    • משאבים בעברית
  • School Leaders
    • School Administrators
    • Professional Development with Ji
      • Upcoming Training
      • Jigzi Training
      • Playful Blended Hebrew Learning – Mini Courses
  • Parents
    • Parents
    • Parent resources
    • PJ Library on Jigzi
  • Insights
    • Ji Blog
    • Ji News
    • Ji’s 18 Min Leaders – Insights into Success
    • What our users say…
  • About Us

What’s the impact on human connection? – Rabbi Effie Kleinberg

    Home Jewish Interactive Blog What’s the impact on human connection? – Rabbi Effie Kleinberg
    NextPrevious

    What’s the impact on human connection? – Rabbi Effie Kleinberg

    By Corinne Ossendryver | Jewish Interactive Blog | 0 comment | 16 August, 2016 | 0

    Rabbi Ephraim KleinbergWe all have those moments. Moments when we think we have made a breakthrough, a game-changing innovation… and then we see it, at first, it appears as a small hole, but then it grows increasingly larger as it comes into view. That gaping hole can shock and even terrify us into that, “What did I just do?!” reaction. Yet, it is these moments of risk-taking and failure which allow us to propel our thinking and our actions forward in ways that had we not taken the chance, we would never have been given the opportunity to deepen our experience and learning.

    A few months ago, I assigned my students a collaborative composition assignment. The class of 17 students shared and worked on the same Google Doc upon which they were tasked with writing short reflective pieces for the upcoming Jewish Holiday of Purim. The students were further broken up into groups of 2 or 3 and worked in those smaller groups on the composition of one creative idea per group. In general with group work, I took the liberty to assign the groups, and in this instance, I attempted to pair students who displayed a similar work ethic, regardless of their writing or research skills.

    In one of the sub-groups, two of the more serious and motivated students in the class clacked away vigorously and enthusiastically on their individual laptops in collaboration with one another, composing their reflective teaching on the Holiday of Purim. I noticed that each of the pair were wearing earbuds connected to their laptops. I understood that they were listening to music on their individual devices, and this background noise assisted them in drowning out the din of the rest of the class to properly focus on the task at hand. I did not comment or make any gestures toward the pair, as I did not want to harm their vibe or flow which appeared to be operating quite smoothly and effectively.

    As the class continued, I seized the opportunity to both walk through and among the groups as well as to monitor in real time the unfolding literary artwork of the students on the Google Doc. At no point during the close to 40 minutes of group work did I hear or see verbal interaction between the pair described above. Their composition was wonderfully and beautifully written, original, thoughtful, and inspiring. Yet, I felt deflated, defeated, and beaten down. I had lost at my own game. I was attempting to be innovative and cutting-edge, but I ended up creating a bit of a monster in the classroom. I could not bring myself to label the activity anything but a failure. I let my students down, even if they didn’t realize it, and I let myself down as well.

    I was so sure that I had created a working concept wherein I was integrating technology, engaging my students, promoting a spirit of collaboration and camaraderie, encouraging student driven learning, where the students became the creators of their own knowledge and content, handing over the torch from the front of the classroom to the center, but I did not foresee the technology becoming a replacement for human connection.

    This moment was a monumental failure in my teaching career. It was a moment that is still very fresh in my mind, and I continue to dwell on the depth of that moment. For me, the ultimate takeaway is that human connection can never be replaced by a technological connection. The nuance of verbal and facial expression cannot be translated or communicated through a screen, but it is really more than that. Open dialogue, disagreement, and ‘fleshing it out’ are crucial components of social and educational norms. Thinking through an issue or an idea by talking it out with a partner are building blocks in human relationships.

    Can technology support our efforts to enhance and improve the dynamics of group learning in our classrooms? Certainly, and without a doubt. The question we must ask ourselves when we embark on a path of technological integration is, “what will this initiative cost us in terms of the impact on human connection?” We can integrate responsibly and successfully, but we can only do it the right way when we put people before machines.

    —

    Rabbi Ephraim Kleinberg (@EffieKleinberg)
    Director of Educational Technology and Religious Growth
    Bnei Akiva Schools, Toronto, ON

    collaboration, disagreement, Google Doc, human connection, open dialogue, Purim, technology

    Corinne Ossendryver

    More posts by Corinne Ossendryver

    Related Posts

    • Going Out on a Limb for Trees

      By Corinne Ossendryver | 0 comment

      Rifki Orzech writes that Tu Bishvat, meaning the 15th of Shevat, is mentioned in the Mishnah as an important date for Jewish farmers. Yes, its beginnings are humble and more to do with the inevitability of taxes than ecology.

    • 8 Ways Chanukah Can Last a Lifetime

      By Corinne Ossendryver | 0 comment

      Rifki Orzech writes that Chanukah is easy. There’s no obligatory home cleaning. There are no melachot and no actual festive meals. It’s practically chol hamoed—for eight days straight!

    • 18 Min Leaders – an Initiative by Ji

      By Corinne Ossendryver | 0 comment

      18 Min Leaders is Ji’s new initiative to share and amplify the voices of Jewish leaders across the global Jewish community.

    • 5 Ways to Celebrate Purim with Pre-Schoolers

      By Corinne Ossendryver | 0 comment

      Rifki Orzech finds 5 ways to celebrate Purim with pre-schoolers. The story of Purim can come to life with shows, songs, costumes and digital stickers. Like many things in life, it’s not about stuffing it all in one week before Purim but knowing it’s there and trying different things every year.

    • Ji Taps into Yom Kippur

      By Corinne Ossendryver | 0 comment

      Some ideas to keep you keep an even keel with young children on Yom Kippur

    Leave a Comment

    Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    NextPrevious

    Categories

    • 4 Kidz by Kidz
    • About-page
    • Bar Mitzvah
    • Ben adam lechavero
    • Ben adam lemakom
    • Biblical Hebrew
    • Brachot (blessings)
    • Case-Studies
    • Chanukah
    • Creative Tools
    • Diaspora and Oral Law
    • Digital Homework Olympics
    • Feedback
    • General calendar
    • General mitzvot
    • Greenfield Hebrew Academy
    • Harkham Hillel Hebrew Academy
    • Havdala
    • Jewish Communities
    • Jewish History
    • Jewish Interactive Blog
    • Ji Blog
    • JI Studio
    • Ji Tap Blog
    • Kashrut
    • Lighting candles
    • Martin J Gottlieb Day School
    • Mashiach
    • Mitzvot
    • My Menorah
    • News Item
    • Pesach/Passover
    • Purim
    • Rosh Hashana
    • Shabbat
    • Shavuot
    • South Africa
    • Spotlight
    • State of Israel
    • Sukkot
    • Tehillim (psalms)
    • Tisha B'av
    • Torah
    • Uncategorized
    • Upcoming Events

    Jewish Interactive

    Donate to Jewish Interactive

    Jewish Interactive is a registered
    501(c)(3) in the US with tax ID 46-1331618

    The Jewish Interactive Educational Trust is a Section 18A (1)(a) in South Africa
    (Registration IT36/2012) (PBO 930 038 343)

    Jewish Interactive is a registered charity
    in the UK (Charity Number 1151408)

    Useful links

    • Jigzi
    • Ji Israel Bytes
    • The Ji Collection (Ji Apps)
    • Ji Studio
    • Products & Services
    • Teachers
    • School Principals & Managers
    • Parents
    • About Us
    • Training and Support
    Jigzi

    Subscribe

    Sign up for newsletter

    Follow us

    Contact us

    Contact Ji

    [email protected]

    Ji United States
    Tel: +1 (866) 601-8000

    Ji United Kingdom
    Tel: +44 (0)79 6641 4417

    Ji South Africa
    Tel: +27 (79) 886 5326

    Ji Israel
    Tel: +972 (0) 54-597 9555

    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Child Protection Policy
    Copyright 2024 Jewish Interactive Inc | All Rights Reserved
    • Home
    • Products & Services
      • Ji Products & Services
      • Jigzi
        • Jigzi Pro Tips
        • Training
      • Curriculum Series
        • Ji Alef-bet: Hebrew Reading Curriculum
        • Hebrew Reading Fast Track
        • Ivrit Misaviv La’Olam – עברית מסביב לעולם
          • Playful Blended Hebrew Learning – Mini Courses 2023
        • Ji Israel Bytes
        • Tales of Jerusalem – ילדים מספרים ירושלים
      • Ji Studio
      • The Ji Collection (Apps)
      • Ji Prime
      • Training & Support
        • Upcoming Training
    • Teachers
      • Ji Teachers
      • Educator resources
      • Professional Development with Ji
        • Upcoming Training
        • Playful Blended Hebrew Learning – Mini Courses 2023
      • משאבים בעברית
    • School Leaders
      • Ji School Administrators
      • Professional Development with Ji
        • Upcoming Training
        • Playful Blended Hebrew Learning – Mini Courses 2023
    • Parents
      • Ji Parents
      • Parent resources
    • About Us
    • Insights
      • Ji Blog
      • Ji News
      • Ji’s 18 Min Leaders – Insights into Success
      • What our users say…
    • Contact Us
    • Donate to Ji
    Jewish Interactive